Welcome to Glass House Sign in | Help

Where Citizen Journalism Works

Great story in the Journal today, looking at how citizen journalists are helping cover what is going on in Myanmar.  Setting aside my dislike for the overly broad use of the term "citizen journalist" in this case, what we're seeing is a good example of how an increasingly connected and video enabled world allows news to flourish even in totalitarian regimes. At the same time, a note of caution properly expressed here (bold mine):

"When traditional methods and professional journalists can't provide footage, and personal safety allows, citizens rise to the challenge time and again, often with remarkable material," said Ellana Lee, the managing editor of CNN Asia Pacific in an email. "Even in countries like Myanmar, the spread of the Internet and mobile phones has meant that footage will always continue to get through and the story will be told, one way or another."

Still, working with inexperienced journalists can be a challenge for news organizations that want to publish credible, balanced information. Reuters, which has a reporter stationed in Yangon, says content from citizen journalists is rigorously checked for accuracy.

My trepidation is that the same trends of rapid transmission of video and photos can as easily be used by those seeking to deceive as by those seeking to enlighten.

Published Friday, September 28, 2007 6:23 AM by FrankShaw

Comments

 

Jacqueline said:

I agree with you on not really liking "citizen journalism", as it seems to imply that professional journalists aren't citizens or something, but something in me really wants to remain positive (positive in the sense that the people who report are being truthful, l mean) about the truth of the reports from Burma.  After all, the military government doesn't have the best track record when it comes to human rights or openness.

Check out my blog (linked in my name) for more thoughts on the citizen journalism that's taking place in Burma/Myanmar, or as is evident from the name, to find out more about the Knight News Challenge.

September 30, 2007 11:24 PM
 

KL said:

All very valid things to keep in mind regarding "citizen journalism." I think one thing that helps filter truth from bias, that can (and will) inevitably pop up in situations like in Myanmar, is the consistency in the accounts being sent out of the country. While entire stories may not be factual, there will be identical red flags that will pop up in each story.

But responsible journalism is a tricky topic. Even the so-called pro's can get caught up in sticky situations. (Stephen Glass, anyone?)

October 1, 2007 3:34 PM
 

FrankShaw said:

There also is the role that the MSM plays in driving a distinction between important and popular. For example, campaign reform, or signing statements, or ballot initiatives are important, but never going to show up on the top of Digg.

How does a world of more distributed news cover important issues?

October 1, 2007 3:39 PM

Leave a Comment

(required) 
(optional)
(required) 

WE reserves the right to refuse to post or to edit or remove, in whole or in part, any Information that is, in WE's sole discretion, unacceptable, undesirable or in violation of these rules.
Submit

Syndication



» Blogs that link here
» View my profile

Powered by Technorati